Evaluation of renal vascular variations with computed tomography
African Journal of Urology volume 28, Article number: 21 (2022)
It is important to know the renal vascular variations before renal surgeries and invasive procedures. The aim of this study is to evaluate the prevalence and types of variation of renal arteries and veins.
The abdominal CT images of 460 patients, taken between 2019 and 2021, were retrospectively analyzed in axial and coronal planes. The presence and number of accessory renal arteries and early branching in the main renal artery were evaluated. Then, bilateral renal vein variations were investigated. Finally, the compression of the left renal vein by different anatomical structures was evaluated.
Of the 450 patients included in the study, the mean age was 53 years. No variations were detected in 378 renal arteries on the right side (84%) and 392 renal arteries on the left side (87.1%). The most common variation in renal arteries was an accessory inferior hilar artery in 7.5% and 6% rates on the right and left, respectively. An accessory inferior renal polar artery was observed at an overall rate of 1.3%. An accessory superior renal hilar artery was found at 3.3% and 2% rates on the left and the right, respectively. An accessory superior renal polar artery was found at an overall rate of 3.5%. Multiple variations in the renal arteries were observed at a rate of 6.4%. Early branching was observed at a rate of 4.9% on the right and 2.2% on the left. The presence of two and three right renal veins was observed at rates of 13.1% and 0.6%, respectively. Retroaortic and circumaortic left renal veins were found at 3.5% and 4.4% rates, respectively. The compression on the anterior and posterior left renal veins was observed at 4.6% and 0.9% rates, respectively.
Considering that variations in renal arteries and veins are too many and of different types to underestimate, a CT examination for the renal vascular anatomy before and at the planning phase of renal surgery or interventional procedures will be of great benefit to avoid potential complications.
The morphology and variations in the renal vascular structures should be known to perform any type of renal surgery, primarily before any renal transplantation surgery or before interventional radiologic procedures such as the treatment of renal artery stenosis and renal mass embolization. Also, it is important to know renal vascular variations before open or endovascular surgery for the treatment of abdominal aortic aneurysms [1, 2]. Conventional angiography is the gold standard method to examine vascular structures; however, it is an invasive procedure and it is not adequate to determine renal vein variations in detail [3, 4]. Multidetector computed tomography (MDCT) is a highly sensitive method, allowing for the examination of the overall renal vascular anatomy along with arteries and veins together [2, 5].
The aim of this study was to investigate the prevalence and types of variations in renal arteries and veins in individuals, who had undergone abdominal MDCT for any reason. Furthermore, our study investigated the rate of compression of the left renal vein by other anatomical structures.
The CT images of 460 patients taken between January 2019 and January 2021, who had undergone an intravenously administered contrast-enhanced CT examination due to any reason in our hospital, were examined retrospectively. Patients with ectopic kidney, congenital kidney anomaly, or patients whose CT images were insufficient for vascular evaluation were excluded from the study.
The abdominal CT examination was performed with a 128-slice multi-detector CT scanner (GE, Optima CT 660). Thin-sliced source images obtained in the axial plan were recalled from PACS and examined retrospectively. Multiplanar reformatted images and maximum intensity projection images were obtained for all patients. All CT images were evaluated by two experienced radiologists, and the reports were prepared in consensus between them. The examinations were performed in the axial and coronal planes. Firstly, renal artery variations were examined. The presence and counts of accessory renal arteries in both kidneys in the axial and coronal planes, their origins in respect to the native renal artery, and their place of entry into the kidney [either from the hilus (hilar) or the cortex (polar)] were determined. Also, the presence of early branching was investigated in renal arteries. Then, the variations in renal veins were investigated in the axial and coronal planes. The right renal vein count and the course of the left renal vein with respect to the abdominal aorta were noted. Finally, the compression of left renal vein by different anatomical structures was evaluated.
Of the 460 patients who were examined, 5 patients were excluded because 3 had ectopic kidney and 2 had horseshoe kidney anomaly. In addition, 5 patients were not included in the study due to insufficient CT images for vascular evaluation. Of the 450 patients (900 kidneys; 249 men and 201 women) included in the study, the mean age was 53 years (age range: 18–83 years).
No variations were detected in 378 renal arteries on the right side (84%) and 392 renal arteries on the left side (87.1%). The most common variation in renal arteries was an accessory inferior hilar artery in 34 (7.5%) patients on the right and 27 (6%) patients on the left (Fig. 1). An accessory inferior renal polar artery was observed in 3 (0.6%) patients on each side, making a total of 6 (1.3%) patients (Fig. 2a). An accessory superior renal hilar artery was observed in 15 (3.3%) patients on the left and 9 (2%) patients on the right, while an accessory superior renal polar artery was observed in 8 (1.8%) patients on each side, making a total of 16 (3.5%) patients. The number of patients, having both superior and inferior accessory arteries was 5 (1.1%).
The number of patients with renal artery variations on both sides was 27 (6%) (Fig. 2c). The number of patients with more than one renal artery variation was 29 (6.4%). Of these patients, the number of patients with two variations was 20 (4.4%), the number of patients with three variations was 6 (1.3%), the number of patients with four variations was 2 (0.4%), and the number of patients with five variations was only 1 (0.2%).
Early branching was observed in a total of 32 (7.1%) patients, 22 (4.9%) on the right and 10 (2.2%) on the left (Fig. 2b). Of the patients with early branching of the renal arteries, early branching artery entered the kidney from the cortex like the renal polar artery in 7 (21.9%) patients.
While the number of patients having left renal vein in front of the abdominal aorta and then coursing normally was 414 (92%), the number of patients with the left renal vein coursing behind the abdominal aorta was 16 (3.5%). The number of patients, having circumaortic left renal veins coursing posteriorly and anteriorly to the abdominal aorta was 20 (4.4%) (Fig. 3c). Left renal vein, coursing anteriorly to the abdominal aorta, was compressed between abdominal aorta and superior mesenteric artery in 21 patients (4.6%); while in 4 patients (0.9%), left renal vein coursed posteriorly to the abdominal aorta and was compressed between abdominal aorta and lumbar vertebrae (the Nutcracker phenomenon) (Fig. 3d, e).
All renal vascular variations detected in our study are presented in Table 1.
CT is an excellent imaging method to evaluate the normal anatomy of renal vascular structures, as well as its variations. The number and course of the renal artery and renal veins could easily and precisely defined by performing a CT angiography . The main renal arteries usually originate from abdominal aorta, at the level of the L1–L2 vertebrae, just below the superior mesenteric artery. The right main renal artery generally originates more superiorly compared to the left renal artery .
Variations in renal vessels may occur due to the atypical position of the kidneys during cephalic migration of the kidneys in embryogenesis. In addition, the number of mesonephric arteries feeding the kidney decreases to one during embryonic development, and abnormalities in this process may cause an increase in the number of ectopic arteries [6, 7].
Accessory renal arteries are clinically the most important variations in renal vascular anatomy, occurring in one-third of patients. Multiple renal arteries are either unilateral or bilateral, accounting for approximately 30% and 10% of the patient population, respectively [3, 4]. In our study, the inferior and superior, and hilar and polar accessory renal artery variations were detected in a total of 107 (23.8%) patients. This finding is similar to the 24% accessory renal artery prevalence found in the study conducted by Ozkan et al. . Studies have reported that accessory renal arteries are seen more frequently on the right side than on the left, although the difference is not statistically significant [6, 8]. In our study, inferior variations and early branching (8.2%, 4.9%, respectively) were more common on the right compared to the left side (6.6% and 2.2%, respectively), while superior variations were more common on the left (5.1%) compared to the right side (3.8%). Overall, the variations were more common on the right (16.8%) compared to the left side (14%).
Accessory arteries can originate from the aorta or iliac arteries anywhere from the level of the T11 vertebra to the level of the L4 vertebra. Rarely, an accessory artery can originate from the lower thoracic aorta or lumbar or mesenteric arteries . In our study, the origins of the accessory arteries were from left main iliac artery in two patients (Fig. 2b). Therefore, radiographic images of patients should visualise the main iliac artery to detect renal vascular variations . Accessory arteries usually course towards the renal hilum to perfuse the upper or lower poles of kidneys. Accessory arteries supplying the poles of the kidneys are usually narrower than accessory renal hilar arteries with calibers similar to those of native renal arteries .
Early (prehilar) arterial branching is another common variant that should be checked in patients, who are evaluated for donor nephrectomy . To obtain a favorable anastomosis during kidney transplantation, it is very important to determine the presence of early branching in the main renal artery, as the renal artery incision is made 1.5–2 cm distal to the origin from the aorta . Several studies in the literature report the rates of early branching from the main renal artery in the range from 6.5 to 12% [5, 6, 8]. In our study, early branching originated from the right and left renal arteries at rates of 4.9% and 2.2%, respectively. In total, early branching was observed in 7.1% of the patients in our study. These rates are compatible with those reported in the literature.
The rate of two or more renal artery variations existing concurrently in a patient was found out to be 6.4% in our study. This rate is lower compared to the rate reported by Çinar et al. . In the study of Çinar et al. , the presence of two concurrent variations in a patient was reported as 22.2%, while the concurrent presence of three, four, and five variations in a patient were reported at rates of 7.5%, 1.4%, and 0.2%, respectively. In our study, those rates were 4.4%, 1.3%, 0.4%, and 0.2%, respectively. A maximum of five concurrent variations was observed in one patient in our study. In this patient having five variations, one accessory inferior renal hilar artery and one accessory inferior renal polar artery were observed on the right, while two accessory inferior renal hilar arteries and one accessory inferior renal polar artery were found on the left. The accessory inferior renal polar artery on the left originated from the left main iliac artery in this patient.
In the study performed by Çinar et al. , the rates of patients with two, three, and four right renal veins were reported to be 19.2%, 2.2%, and 0.2%, respectively. In our study, the rates of the concurrent presence of more than one renal vein in a patient were found out to be lower than those reported by Çinar et al. . In our study, the rate of patients with two right renal veins was 13.1% and the rate of patients with three right renal veins was 0.6%. No patients were found to have four renal veins in our study. Çinar et al.  reported the presence of left retroaortic renal veins and circumaortic left renal veins at rates of 4.2% and 5.2%, respectively. Those rates are partially compatible with these found in our study, as left retroaortic veins and circumaortic left renal veins were detected at rates of 3.5% and 4.4%, respectively.
Due to the long course of the left renal vein, the left kidney is preferred in donor nephrectomy. Therefore, it is vital to know the course of the left renal vein before the surgery [11, 12]. Left renal vein variations rarely manifest with clinical symptoms. Most of them are revealed by imaging methods . Rare clinical symptoms of anatomical variations of the left renal vein include proteinuria, hematuria, varicocele in men, and the pelvic varicocele in the left ovary in women [14,15,16].
Nutcracker syndrome (NCS) describes the compression on the left renal vein trapped between SMA and abdominal aorta (meso-aortic trap). While NCS is a clinical diagnosis, the Nutcracker phenomenon only refers to the radiological compression of left renal vein between the SMA and aorta . The symptoms of NCS are variable depending on the capacity of developing collateral vasculature via compensatory mechanisms. Individuals with NCS can be asymptomatic, too. NCS can be clinically diagnosed when left-sided pain, varicocele, proteinuria, and anemia occur [18, 19]. The posterior nutcracker phenomenon is a variant characterized by compression of left renal vein between aorta and vertebral column . In the study by Poyraz et al. , the prevalences of anterior and posterior left renal vein compression were 4.1% and 6.5%, respectively. In another study, posterior left renal vein compression was found at a rate of 2.06% . In our study, the rate of anterior left renal vein compression was 4.6% and this rate was compatible with that reported in the previous study. However, the frequency of posterior left renal vein compression was 0.9% in our study and was lower compared to the rate reported in the previous study. However, when only the patients with retroaortic left renal veins were examined in our study, the nutcracker phenomenon was detected in 4 out of 16 patients (25%) with retroaortic left renal veins in which the incidence is quite high.
One of the limitations of our study is that some patients were excluded because the enhancement in renal venous structures was sometimes not at the desired level and did not allow optimal evaluation.
In our study, we concluded that variations in renal arteries and veins were very high. Considering that variations are too many and of different types to underestimate, a CT examination of the renal vascular anatomy before and at the planning phase of renal surgery or interventional procedures will be of great benefit to avoid potential complications.
Availability of data and materials
Hänninen EL, Denecke T, Stelter L et al (2005) Preoperative evaluation of living kidney donors using multirow detectorcomputed tomography: comparison with digital subtractionangiography and intraoperative findings. Transpl Int 18:1134–1141
Turkvatan A, Akinci S, Yildiz S, Olçer T, Cumhur T (2009) Multi-detector computed tomography for preoperative evaluation of vascular anatomy in living renal donors. Surg Radiol Anat 31:227–235
Kadir S (1986) Angiography of the kidneys. In: Kadir S (ed) Diagnostic angiography. Saunders, Philadelphia, pp 445–495
Spring DB, Salvatierra O Jr, Palubinskas AJ, Amend WJ, Vincenti FG, Feduska NJ (1979) Results and significance of angiography in potential kidney donors. Radiology 133:45–47
Çinar C, Türkvatan A (2016) Prevalence of renal vascular variations: evaluation with MDCT angiography. Diagn Interv Imaging 97:891–897
Ozkan U, Oğuzkurt L, Tercan F, Kizilkiliç O, Koç Z, Koca N (2006) Renal artery origins and variations: angiographic evaluation of 855 consecutive patients. Diagn Interv Radiol 12:183–186
Sykes D (1963) The arterial supply of the human kidney with special reference to accessory renal arteries. Br J Surg 50:368–374
Holden A, Smith A, Dukes P, Pilmore H, Yasutomi M (2005) Assessment of 100 live potential renal donors for laparoscopicnephrectomy with multi-detector row helical CT. Radiology 237:973–980
Dachman AH, Newmark GM, Mitchell MT, Woodle ES (1998) Helical CT examination of potential kidney donors. AJR 171:193–200
Urban BA, Ratner LE, Fishman EK (2001) Three-dimensional volume-rendered CT angiography of the renal arteries and veins:normal anatomy, variants, and clinical applications. Radiographics 21:373–386
Turner RJ, Young SW, Castellino RA (1980) Dynamic continuous computed tomography: study of retroaortic left renal vein. J Comput Assist Tomogr 4(1):109–111
Deák PÁ, Doros A, Lovró Z et al (2011) The significance of the circumaortic left renal vein and other venous variations in laparoscopic living donor nephrectomies. Transplant Proc 43(4):1230–1232
Trigaux JP, Vandroogenbroek S, De Wispelaere JF, Lacrosse M, Jamart J (1998) Congenital anomalies of the inferior vena cava and left renalvein: evaluation with spiral CT. J Vasc Interv Radiol 9(2):339–345
Arslan H, Etlik O, Ceylan K, Temizoz O, Harman M, Kavan M (2005) Incidence of retro-aortic left renal vein and its relationship with varicocele. Eur Radiol 15(8):1717–1720
Nam JK, Park SW, Lee SD, Chung MK (2010) The clinical significance of a retroaortic left renal vein. Korean J Urol 51(4):276–280
Koc Z, Ulusan S, Oguzkurt L, Tokmak N (2007) Venous variants and anomalies on routine abdominal multi-detector row CT. Eur J Radiol 61(2):267–278
Kurklinsky AK, Rooke TW (2010) Nutcracker phenomenon and nutcracker syndrome. Mayo Clin Proc 85:552–559
Orczyk K, Łabetowicz P, Lodziński S, Stefanczyk L, Topol M, Polguj M (2016) The nutcracker syndrome. Morphology and clinical aspects of the important vascular variations: a systematic study of 112 cases. Int Angiol 35:71–77
Lamba R, Tanner DT, Sekhon S, McGahan JP, Corwin MT, Lall CG (2014) Multidetector CT of vascular compression syndromes in the abdomen and pelvis. Radiographics 34:93–115
Ahmed K, Sampath R, Khan MS (2006) Current trends in the diagnosis and management of renal nutcracker syndrome: a review. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg 31(4):410–416
Poyraz AK, Firdolas F, Onur MR, Kocakoc E (2013) Evaluation of left renal vein entrapment using multidetector computed tomography. Acta Radiol 54(2):144–148
Shi Y, Yang H, Feng Z, Chen F, Zhang H, Wu Z (2018) Evaluation of posterior nutcracker phenomenon using multisection spiral CT. Clin Radiol 73(12):1060.e9–1060.e16
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This study has been approved by the Ethics Committee of the Diskapi Yildirim Beyazit Training and Research Hospital (Protocol number: 79/07-2020). All methods were performed in accordance with the relevant guidelines and regulations. Consent for participation from all the patients has been taken.
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Hekimoglu, A., Ergun, O. Evaluation of renal vascular variations with computed tomography. Afr J Urol 28, 21 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12301-022-00290-x
- Renal artery
- Renal vein
- Morphological findings