- Original Research
- Open Access
Prevalence of urinary symptoms and infections among traditional tannery workers in the Fez city of Morocco: case–control study
African Journal of Urology volume 27, Article number: 136 (2021)
Many work activities such as leather tanning include hazards to work. Among these, biological hazards are particularly important and pose a serious problem to human health and environment. The aims of this study were to estimate the prevalence of dysuria and urinary tract infections among tannery workers and to identify their risk factors.
This observational survey was conducted among 220 tannery workers and 220 age-matched control group from Fez city in Morocco. Reported urinary symptoms, demographic and professional information were obtained by a standardized questionnaire collected from participants and were then compared among the two groups. The logistic regression model was used to explore the interaction between variables with significant association.
The most common symptoms reported by tannery workers and controls were dysuria (36.4% vs. 1.8%, p < 0.001), voiding frequency (15.5% vs. 0.9%, p < 0.001) and incontinence (3.2% vs. 0.5%, p < 0.001). A positive urinary culture was seen in 3.64% of the tannery workers but not in the controls (0%). E-coli was the only species. Multivariate logistic regression showed that exposure to biological hazards increased significantly the odds of dysuria by 6.76 times (CI 1.112–41.78; p = 0.038) but rather, low or normal weight was a protective factor of dysuria (OR 0.53; CI 0.249–0.950; p = 0.035).
Multiple working conditions including exposure to biological hazards may cause an increase in urogenital disorders in the tannery workers. A significantly higher prevalence of urinary symptoms among male workers demand serious attention and further investigation.
Recently, infectious diseases including microorganisms have been identified as the most common occupational diseases . In the tanning sector, the processing of animal hides requires significant water usage, causing a high humidity working environment, when combined with elevated temperature and low oxygen concentration, the high-humidity environment acts as a catalyst for microbial growth [3, 11]. The raw skins containing carbohydrates, fats and proteins, as well as a high moisture content, provide an ideal medium for the rapid reproduction of microorganisms . In addition to the working environment and raw skins, some tannery agents, such as oils, greases, pigeon dungs, and protein binders, also provide nutrients for microorganism propagation [8, 13]. An association between infectious diseases, humidity and temperature has been established because most of bacteria and fungi require specific environmental conditions to proliferate . The most frequent bacteria isolated from hides and skins delivered directly to the tannery without prior treatment include: Escherichia coli, Staphylococcus epidermidis, Morganella morganii, Proteus mirabilis, Proteus vulgaris, Bacillus anthracis, Bacillus subtilis, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Lactobacillus Jensen and Bacillus mycoides [3, 19]. The possibility of contracting urinary infection is a constant hazard for the tannery workers, because the animal skin and leather product contain many microorganisms that have been identified in urogenital diseases . For example, Escherichia coli and Enterobacter species can cause urinary tract infection, wound infection and abscesses septicaemia.
Symptoms of urinary tract infection (UTI), particularly dysuria, become more prevalent in men with increasing age. Although many physicians equate dysuria with UTI, it is actually a symptom that has many potential causes. Any source of irritation or inflammation of the urinary tract, particularly the bladder, prostate or urethra, can cause dysuria [2, 9]. It is difficult to draw conclusions about causes from comparisons of symptoms. However, such comparisons are useful in describing the subjects-perceived problems, and within country analyses may help to improve methods for the study of urological conditions.
Therefore, information on biological hazards related to urinary tracts in tannery workers has not been widely researched, which justifies this study and demonstrates its importance. Therefore, this study was designed to estimate the prevalence of urinary symptoms and urinary tract infection in tannery workers and to identify associated factors.
Study design and participants
This case–control study was conducted in traditional tanneries of Fez city in Morocco from September 2017 to March 2018. It has included 220 male tannery workers aged ≥ 18 years having at least one year of work experience, and 220 age-matched male subject (control group). The selection of the control group was collected randomly from different activities (textile workers, administrative personnel and sellers in the informal sectors).
For each participant, demographic data including age, education level, marital status and smoking habits were investigated. Other occupational conditions including duration of work, exposure to biological hazards (raw skins and pigeon dungs that may be contaminated with a variety of bacteria, molds, virus, yeasts and various diseases), working environment: humid area (tasks in the basins) and dry place (tasks far from the basins) were collected from the tannery workers by a questionnaire-based interview. Participant tanners were also asked to determine the status of the use of Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) regarding boots and gloves. In addition, Urinary Tract symptoms (UTS) and related hygienic conditions were also collected including a total of 7 questions (increased daytime frequency, nocturia, urgency, incontinence, dysuria, frequency of toilet break access and use tissue/water after toilet). The personal medical history including blood pressure (BP) and body mass index (BMI) of participants were measured following standard procedures. This index classifies the nutritional status of the subject into four categories: underweight < 18.5 kg/m2, normal 18.5–24.9 kg/m2, overweight 25.0–29.9 kg/m2 and obese ≥ 30 kg/m2.
The participants were asked to provide a fresh 10 ml spot urine sample in the morning of a normal working day. The urine cytology was quantitatively performed using the Sysmex UF-1000i urinary system (TOA Medical Electronics, Kobe, Japan) to estimate white blood cell (WBC) count, red blood cell (RBC) count and bacteria. All urine samples were examined on the same day as the urine samples were delivered.
Urines were cultured and incubated at 37 °C for 24 h. Presumptive Enterobacteriaceae (oxidase-negative, facultative aerobic, Gram-negative rods) were identified by using the API 20E system (bioMérieux, Marcy-l’Étoile, France) and confirmed by method automated on Phoenix. Antimicrobial susceptibility was determined as recommended by the French Society of Microbiology (SFM, 2013).
UCBE interpretation was performed according to the guidelines mentioned in the medical microbiology guidelines (REMIC) . More than 104 cells/ml was considered as abnormal value for the number of average RBC and WBC in the urine.
A participant was diagnosed as having a UTI if they had clinical symptoms of UTI and the urinalysis showed bacteria (bacteriuria). Significant bacteriuria was defined as ≥ 103 colony-forming units (CFUs)/ml of a single bacterial species in a freshly voided sample of urine as mentioned in the 2015 French guidelines .
The descriptive statistics technique was used for the description of demographic variables. The prevalence of urinary symptoms and UTI were reported. The Chi-square test was used to establish the possible associations between the presence of dysuria, demographic and occupational parameters. Parameters with p < 0.05 were considered statistically significant. The binary logistic regression model was used as a multivariate analysis to determine the factors related to dysuria. Data analysis was performed using the statistical software package SPSS 17.0.
General characteristics, prevalence of urinary symptoms and hygienic conditions among tannery workers and control group
Data collection in the current study was completed from 220 tannery workers and 220 control group. Demographic, clinical history and occupational characteristics of the two groups are presented in Table 1. Results showed that more than half of tannery workers (52.7%) were between 40 and 60 years of age, 28.2% were relatively young and 84.5% were married. Then, they were likely to be more sexually active. No significant difference was found between tannery workers and controls with respect to age, smoking habit and marital status. Smoking was slightly more frequent in tannery workers than the control group (29.1% vs. 20.9%, p = 0.61). Primary school was the most prevalent education level in tannery workers (49.5%) compared to control group (28.2%). For occupational parameters, the majority of tannery workers (72.3%) were involved in a humid area in these tanneries. Moreover, 73.6% of them were exposed to various biological hazards and 69.5% of them they did not use any type of professional protective equipment.
Table 2 shows that the tannery workers had a higher prevalence of many urinary symptoms and related work conditions, except for nocturia which was significantly higher in the control group.
In particular, tannery workers had a significantly higher prevalence of dysuria compared to controls (36.4% vs. 1.8%, p < 0.001). No significant difference was found in the prevalence of urinary incontinence between the two groups. In terms of toilet access and hygiene measures, about half of tannery workers (49.1%) and 40.4% of comparison group require 3 or more toilet breaks in a day. Moreover, very few of them reported they did not use tissue/water after using a toilet.
The results of UCBE are displayed in Table 3. A significant number of tannery workers had ≥ 104 RBCs (hematuria) and ≥ 104 WBCs (leucocyturia) in their urine, where the number of hematuria and leucocyturia in tannery workers was higher than those of the control group (22.7% vs. 1.8%, p < 0.001 and 10.9% vs. 1.8%, p < 0.001; respectively). Urinary tract infection was detected among 8 (3.64%) of the tannery workers but not in the controls (0%).
E. coli was the unique species isolated from the tannery workers having a positive culture. Chi-square-test results of urinary parameters showed significant differences between the tannery workers and controls, which indicates that tannery workers had a higher risk of urinary system abnormalities than those of the controls (Table 3). Multivariate logistic regression of urinary tract confirmed by bacteriological examination, socio-demographic and occupational factors showed no association in tannery workers and controls (p > 0.05).
Association between socio-demographic parameters, work conditions and the presence of dysuria in tannery workers
The results of the association between socio-demographic characteristics, work conditions and the presence of dysuria in tannery workers, are indexed in Table 4 and considered as candidate variables to the multivariate analysis. In terms of age, workers being more than 40 years showed more urinary symptoms than young ones. However, the Chi-square test shows no significant relationship between age and dysuria (p = 0.27). A statistically significant relationship was established between BMI and dysuria (p = 0.018). Moreover, the educational level, marital status, smoking habits and diabetes do not affect the reported dysuria in tannery workers. The statistically significant predictors of dysuria were biological hazards exposure (p = 0.003) and working area (p = 0.017). Since the tannery workers had direct exposure to biological hazards without appropriate PPE, the Chi-square test shows no significant relationship between the use of PPE and the onset of the reported dysuria (p = 0.425). Workers who have high blood pressure (HBP) are not the most affected by dysuria symptom. In spite of this, Chi-square test represents a statistically significant relationship between the presence of HBP and reported dysuria (p = 0.027).
Multivariate logistic regression analysis of factors associated with dysuria in tannery workers, demographic characteristics and work conditions
The logistic regression model was used to explore the interaction between variables with significant association with dysuria symptom in the Chi-square test already done (Table 5). In this step, a logistic regression model has been conducted to explore the interaction between parameters with a significant association with dysuria in the Chi-square test already done. The OR brut and OR adjusted have been compared to each selected variable. Results showed that exposure to biological hazards was the major risk factor that increased 6 times or more the risk of developing dysuria with (ORa = 6.76, CI = 1.107–41.349, p = 0.038). In contrast, having low or normal weight (BMI < 25 kg/m2) was an independent protective factor of dysuria after adjusting which had an adjusted OR of 0.53 and a 95% CI of 0.249–0.950 (p = 0.035).
The present study reports an important health issue on urinary disorders among workers from traditional leather tanneries as well as compares these disorders with the control group. In terms of toilet access and hygiene measures, about half of tannery workers require 3 or more toilet breaks and the majority of them use tissue/water after toilet. More than two thirds of tanners do not use any type of PPE. However, they reported that the use of PPE was impractical due to the high humidity in Moroccan artisanal tanneries, especially in summer. The high rate of low educational level as one of the factor limited knowledge about the existing health hazards and safety risks at work. Thus, they are at increased risk of contaminants from all possible routes including the oral, inhalation, ocular and dermal.
Regarding voiding problems, the results of our study showed a significant difference urinary tract symptoms (UTS) for voiding problems including dysuria and urinary frequency between the tannery workers and control group. It is true that UTS are not specific and can be increased by factors unrelated to prostatic conditions, fluid intake, including diet and alcohol intake [1, 23, 26]. The finding may sound alarming because many of them report that they suffer from burning urination and uncontrollable urine loss during work. Out of 111 (55%) tannery workers with urinary symptoms, 3.67% had significant bacteriuria as confirmed by bacteriological examination. In comparison with symptomatic controls (1.8%), no bacteriuria were identified (0%). E. coli was the only specie isolated among tannery workers having positive culture. Some infectious diseases such as UTI caused by E. coli are common in the general population, which complicates the attribution to the workplace . According to the Biological Agent Biodefense Category listed in the World Health Organization (WHO) and the National Institute of Health (NIH), E. coli is a pathogen that does not constitute a serious hazard to the community or to the environment . On the other hand, Chinese Laboratory Biosafety Categorization has classified E. coli as a pathogenic agent that can spread easily between people, directly or indirectly, and can cause serious human disease . In the general population, there are several causes of culture-negative urinary tract symptoms including antibiotics in urine, urinary tract malignancy, idiopathic interstitial cystitis, mycobacterial infection, Schistosoma haematobium, fungal infection, viral infection, inflammation or fastidious organisms . A major factors that impact UTI incidence in our study includes poor hygienic conditions, working in a humid area and exposure to biological hazard especially, in the traditional working environment. In agreement with our study, poor sanitation, hygienic measures have a major influence on E. coli species . However, protection strategies, as well as monitoring, are recommended for this community.
Urinalysis is a useful tool to identify not only infection, but also blood counts. In the current study, the hematuria was significantly prevalent in the tannery population compared to the control group (22.9% vs. 1.9%, p < 10–3). The prevalence of hematuria found in our control group (1.9%) was lower than that reported in large previous screening studies among the general population which varied from 9 to 18% [12, 17, 21], particularly in the male population presenting to a health fair (8.6%) . The multivariate analysis of factors associated with hematuria was conducted and showed no increased risk in the tanners' population. Previous risk factors identified of urinary tract malignancy diagnosed following hematuria were age, smoking, the presence of gross hematuria and positive cytology [4, 17]. Moreover, diabetes and proteinuria were also associated with hematuria in another research .
The prevalence of leucocyturia (WBC > 104), in the present study, was significantly higher in the tannery workers compared to that of the control group (10.9% vs. 1.8%, p < 10–3). It was reported that the leukocyturia could suggest sterile pyuria and cannot reflect the possibility of bacteriuria. However, main Clinical Associations including acute or chronic interstitial nephritis, proliferative glomerulonephritis and urological disorders were reported . In such cases, the correct interpretation of the urinary findings requires adequate clinical information and possibly renal biopsy.
Several studies have demonstrated that voiding symptoms among men increase significantly with age and functional disability [16, 21]. Other factors have been implicated in the dysuria progression including metabolic disorders . Data from previous studies highlight an association between high blood pressure, high BMI, diabetes and urinary disorders including dysuria [7, 23, 27]. In the present study, the risk to develop dysuria was associated with different factors such as BMI and high blood pressure but not necessarily age. Thus, multiple working conditions were also found to be correlated with increased risk of dysuria including working area and exposure to biological hazards. These factors are significant in bivariate analysis. The choice of the symptom 'dysuria' for logistic regression was due to the elevated rate of this symptom compared to others reported in the current study. The multivariate logistic regression analysis of factors associated with reported dysuria symptom investigates that exposure to biological hazards increased significantly the odds of dysuria by 6.76 times. However, having low or normal weight (BMI < 25 kg/m2) was an independent protective factor of dysuria. In fact, it is difficult to draw a firm conclusion about causes from observational comparisons of symptoms. Nevertheless, such comparisons are useful in describing the workers-perceived problems in the traditional work environment, to prevent various complications and improve working conditions.
In this context, a significantly higher prevalence of urinary symptoms among male workers demands a serious attention and further investigation. The low number of occupational diseases linked to biological agents should not lead to an underestimation of biological risks, but should be used as a basis for a decision to reduce the number of occupational risks. Since the exposure of traditional tannery workers to biological agents cannot be avoided, it will be reduced by the establishment of occupational health program based on the development of inter-enterprise medical service (pre-employment and periodic), the organization of medical surveillance program and provision of information/training about hazards and risks in the workplace.
The present study suggests that multiple working conditions, including humid area and exposure to biological hazards, may cause an increase in the urinary tracts in the tannery workers. A significantly higher prevalence of urinary symptoms among male workers demands serious attention and further investigation. In order to prevent health issues among the tannery workers, we suggest that medical observation, including pre-employment and periodic medical controls, should be performed.
Availability of data and materials
Adedeji TG, Fasanmade AA, Olapade-olaopa EO (2016) An association between diet, metabolic syndrome and lower urinary tract symptoms. Afr J Urol 22(2):61–66. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.afju.2015.11.002
Bremnor JD, Sadovsky R (2002) Evaluation of dysuria in adults. Am Fam Phys 65(8):1589–1597
Castellanos-Arévalo DC, Castellanos-Arévalo AP, Camarena-Pozos DA, Colli-Mull JG, Maldonado-Vega M (2015) Evaluation of microbial load in oropharyngeal mucosa from tannery workers. Saf Health Work 6(1):62–70. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.shaw.2014.09.003
Cha EK, Christian LT, Joerg S (2012) Accurate risk assessment of patients with asymptomatic hematuria for the presence of bladder cancer. World J Urol 30:847–852
Chervet D, Lortholary O, Zahar J, Dufougeray A, Pilmis B, Partouche H (2017) Antimicrobial resistance in community-acquired urinary tract infections in Paris in 2015. Medecine et Maladies Infectieuses 48(3):188–192. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.medmal.2017.09.013
Courtemanche K, Chan P, Kassouf W (2019) Prevalence and associated factors for dipstick microscopic hematuria in men. BMC Urol 19(76):1–4
Diagne NS, Nkhachat A, Azanmasso H, Tchonda E, Belhai K, Tahiri A, Lmidmani F, Diop AG, Ndiaye MM, El Fatimi A (2014) Quality of life and urinary disorders in metabolic syndrome. Am J Biomed Life Sci 2(4):78–82
Essahale A, Malki M, Marín I, Moumni M (2010) Bacterial diversity in Fez tanneries and Morocco’s Binlamdoune River, using 16S RNA gene based fingerprinting. J Environ Sci 22(12):1944–1953
Fried M (2018) Dysuria. In: Sydney E, Weinstein E, Rucker LM (eds) Handbook of outpatient medicine. Springer International Publishing, Cham, pp 451–464. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-68379-9_28
Glover EK (2019) Urinary tract infection key points. Medicine 47(9):6–10. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mpmed.2019.06.008
Griffin DW (2007) Atmospheric movement of microorganisms in clouds of desert dust and implications for human health. Clin Microbiol Rev 20(3):459–477
Grossfeld GD, Litwin MS, Wolf JS, Hricak H, Shuler CL, Agerter DC, Carroll PR (2001) Evaluation of asymptomatic microscopic hematuria in adults: the American urological association best practice policy—partie: Definition, detection, prevalence, and etiology. Urology 57(4):599–603
Harchli EEH, Houssaini Iraqui M, Ibnsouda Koraichi S, Krishnan S (2015) Contribution À La Caractérisation Microbiologique et Enzymatique d’un Site Extrême : Les Tanneries Traditionnelles de Fès. Int J Eng Sci 5(2):16–24
Institut National de Recherche et de Sécurité (INRS) (2019) Les risques biologiques en milieu professionnel
Lina G, Bonnet R, Bru J, Caron F, Cattoen C, Cattoir V, Courvalin P, Dubreuil L, Jarlier V, Lefort A (2018) Comité de l’antibiogramme de la Société Française de Microbiologie Recommandations 2018
Liu S, Chuang Y, Sumarsono B (2019) The prevalence and bother of lower urinary tract symptoms in men and women aged 40 years or over in Taiwan. J Formosan Med Assoc 118(1):170–178. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfma.2018.03.006
Loo RK, Lieberman SF, Slezak JM, Landa HM, Mariani AJ, Nicolaisen G, Aspera AM, Jacobsen SJ (2013) Stratifying risk of urinary tract malignant. Mayo Clinic Proc 88(2):129–138. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mayocp.2012.10.004
Orlita A (2004) Microbial biodeterioration of leather and its control: a review. Int Biodeterior Biodegrad 53(3):157–163
Oruko RO, John OO, Edokpayi JN, Abstract (2019) The role of leather microbes in human health. In: We are IntechOpen,the world’s leading publisher of Open Access Books Built by scientists, for scientists. pp 1–17
Padma V, Anand NN, Karthikeyan R, Madhumidha K, Javi MSA, Mituldevan R (2016) Occupational health hazards among the workers in leather tanneries near chromepet. Biomedicine (India) 36(4):109–112
Qvigstad C, Tait RC, de Moerloose P, Holme PA (2020) Hematuria in aging men with hemophilia: Association with factor prophylaxis. Res Pract Thromb Haemost 4(2):309–317
Rim KT, Lim CH (2014) Biologically hazardous agents at work and efforts to protect workers’ health: a review of recent reports. Saf Health Work 5(2):43–52. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.shaw.2014.03.006
Robertson C, Link CL, Onel E, Mazzetta C, Keech M, Hobbs R, Fourcade R, Kiemeney L, Lee C, Boyle P, Mckinlay JB (2007) The impact of lower urinary tract symptoms and comorbidities on quality of life : the BACH and UREPIK studies. BJU Int 99:347–354
Sinha S, Mallick S, Misra RK, Singh S, Basant A, Gupta AK (2007) Uptake and translocation of metals in Spinacia oleracea L. grown on tannery sludge-amended and contaminated soils: effect on lipid peroxidation, morpho-anatomical changes and antioxidants. Chemosphere 67(1):176–187
Tian D, Zheng T (2014) Comparison and analysis of biological agent category lists based on biosafety and biodefense. PLoS ONE 9(6):1–6
Tomita K, Mizoue T, Matsumoto T (2009) Clinical Investigation Lower urinary tract symptoms in relation to lifestyle and medical conditions in Japanese workers. Int J Urol 16(5):493–498
Zimmet P, Magliano D, Matsuzawa Y, Alberti G, Shaw J (2005) The Metabolic syndrome : a global public health problem and a new definition. J Atheroscler Thromb 12(6):295–300
Zubair KU, Shah AH (2019) Frequency of urinary tract infection and antibiotic sensitivity of uropathogens in patients with diabetes. Pak J Med Sci 35(6):1664–1668
This research work was carried out within the framework of an agreement between the Faculty of Medicine and Pharmacy of Fez and the Ministry of Tourism, Handicraft, Air Transport and Social Economy of Morocco. The authors are grateful to these two organizations for financial support. The authors also thank the respondents of the study.
Ministry of Crafts, Social Economy and Solidarity of Morocco.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The current survey was designed in accordance with legal requirements and the Declaration of Helsinki and was approved by the Joint Research Ethics Committee of Medical School and university Hospital Hassan II of Fez, Morocco (Number 29/16)”. People who accepted to participate in the study were requested to provide written informed consent. The UCBE analysis results were interpreted and delivered to the subjects confidentially.
Consent for publication
The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Ilham, A., Hasnae, H., Btissam, A. et al. Prevalence of urinary symptoms and infections among traditional tannery workers in the Fez city of Morocco: case–control study. Afr J Urol 27, 136 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12301-021-00232-z
- Biological hazards
- Tannery workers
- Risk factors
- Urinary tract infection